What Ingredients Should You Avoid in Homemade Cat and Dog Food?

More pet owners are turning to homemade food for their cats and dogs. The motivation is understandable: making meals at home gives you more control over what goes into your pet’s bowl. You can avoid fillers, preservatives, and low-quality ingredients often found in commercial pet food.

But with this control comes responsibility. Not all human foods are safe for pets, and even ingredients that seem harmless may have toxic or long-term negative effects. Cats and dogs have unique nutritional needs and metabolisms that differ drastically from humans. Feeding the wrong ingredients could cause anything from mild digestive upset to life-threatening conditions.

In this article, we’ll explore the ingredients to avoid in homemade pet food, why they’re dangerous, and what safer alternatives you can consider. Whether you’re preparing meals for your cat, dog, or both, this guide will help you create nutritious food while minimizing risk.

Why Knowing Ingredients to Avoid in Homemade Pet Food Is Crucial

Homemade meals can be beneficial if balanced correctly. However, well-meaning pet owners sometimes include foods they enjoy themselves, unaware that these ingredients can be toxic to cats and dogs.

Nutritional Differences Between Cats and Dogs

  • Cats are obligate carnivores – They need high amounts of protein, taurine, and other nutrients found only in animal tissue. They cannot thrive on plant-heavy diets.
  • Dogs are omnivores – They can digest a wider range of foods, but not everything safe for humans is safe for them.

Potential Risks of Unsafe Ingredients

  • Toxicity – Some foods (like onions or chocolate) can be fatal even in small amounts.
  • Digestive upset – Others may cause vomiting, diarrhea, or pancreatitis.
  • Long-term deficiencies or organ damage – Feeding unbalanced or harmful diets repeatedly can lead to serious illness.

Understanding what not to feed is as important as knowing what to include.

Common Ingredients to Avoid in Homemade Pet Food

Below is a detailed list of ingredients that should never be part of your cat or dog’s homemade diet.

 Allium Family (Onions, Garlic, Chives, Leeks)

These are among the most dangerous foods for both cats and dogs.

  • Why they’re harmful: They contain thiosulfates, which damage red blood cells and cause anemia.
  • Symptoms: Weakness, pale gums, vomiting, lethargy, collapse.
  • Note: Even powdered or cooked forms are toxic.

Grapes and Raisins

  • Why they’re harmful: They can cause sudden kidney failure in dogs. The toxic compound isn’t fully understood, but even small amounts can be deadly.
  • Cats: Less likely to eat grapes, but still unsafe.
  • Symptoms: Vomiting, lethargy, reduced appetite, decreased urination.

Chocolate and Caffeine

  • Why they’re harmful: Contain theobromine and caffeine, which are toxic to pets. Dark chocolate and cocoa powder are especially dangerous.
  • Symptoms: Hyperactivity, tremors, irregular heartbeat, seizures, death.

Alcohol and Fermented Foods

  • Why they’re harmful: Alcohol causes severe liver and brain damage. Even small quantities can be fatal. Fermented dough can produce alcohol in the stomach.
  • Symptoms: Vomiting, disorientation, breathing issues, coma.

Artificial Sweeteners (Xylitol)

  • Why they’re harmful: Xylitol triggers rapid insulin release in dogs, leading to hypoglycemia (low blood sugar) and liver failure.
  • Symptoms: Weakness, seizures, collapse.
  • Cats: Less sensitive but still unsafe.

 Bones (Cooked or Brittle)

  • Why they’re harmful: Cooked bones splinter easily, leading to choking, internal blockages, or tears.
  • Raw bones: Sometimes included in raw diets, but must be chosen carefully.

Raw Dough and Yeast

  • Why they’re harmful: Expands in the stomach, causing painful bloating and risk of gastric rupture. Produces alcohol during fermentation.

Dairy Products

  • Why they’re harmful: Many pets are lactose intolerant. Dairy can cause diarrhea, gas, and stomach pain.
  • Exceptions: Small amounts of plain yogurt or cheese may be tolerated, but it’s not essential to their diet.

Certain Nuts

  • Macadamia nuts: Toxic to dogs, causing weakness, tremors, and vomiting.
  • Walnuts, pecans, almonds: Can cause stomach upset or intestinal blockages.
  • High fat: Nuts in general are risky due to their fat content, which can trigger pancreatitis.

Fatty and Fried Foods

  • Why they’re harmful: Excess fat stresses the pancreas, leading to pancreatitis, a painful and dangerous condition.
  • Examples: Bacon grease, fried meats, fast-food leftovers.

Salt and Salty Snacks

  • Why they’re harmful: Excess sodium causes dehydration, electrolyte imbalance, and potential kidney strain.
  • Examples: Chips, cured meats, salty broths.

Raw Fish (Certain Types)

  • Why they’re harmful: Some raw fish contain thiaminase, which destroys vitamin B1 (thiamine) and can lead to neurological issues.
  • Parasites: Uncooked fish may carry harmful parasites.

Raw Eggs

  • Why they’re harmful: Risk of salmonella and avidin (in egg whites) interfering with biotin absorption if fed raw frequently.
  • Safer option: Cooked eggs in moderation.

Liver (Excessive Amounts)

  • Why it’s harmful: In small amounts, liver is nutritious. But too much causes vitamin A toxicity, leading to bone deformities and liver damage.

Spices and Seasonings

  • Why they’re harmful: Many spices (nutmeg, chili powder, salt-heavy seasoning) irritate pets’ stomachs and some are outright toxic.
  • Rule of thumb: Stick to plain, unseasoned food for pets.

Unsafe Fruits and Vegetables

Not all produce is safe. Avoid:

  • Avocado: Contains persin, toxic to many animals.
  • Tomatoes (green parts): Solanine can be harmful.
  • Mushrooms (wild varieties): Some are fatally toxic.

Human Medications and Supplements in Food

Why they’re harmful: Drugs like acetaminophen, ibuprofen, or even certain vitamins (iron, vitamin D) are toxic to pets. Never add human supplements to meals without veterinary guidance.

Special Considerations: Cats vs. Dogs

Cats

  • Extremely sensitive to onion, garlic, and certain medications.
  • Require taurine (an amino acid only found in animal tissue). A homemade diet lacking taurine leads to blindness and heart disease.
  • Less likely to eat sweet foods but still vulnerable to toxins.

Dogs

  • More likely to scavenge or eat large quantities of unsafe food.
  • Highly sensitive to grapes, raisins, chocolate, and xylitol.
  • Need careful balance of protein, fat, and carbs to avoid obesity.

Safe Alternatives for Homemade Pet Food

If you’re making meals at home, here are safer ingredients to focus on:

Proteins

  • Cooked chicken, turkey, lean beef, or fish (without bones or seasoning).
  • Eggs (cooked).

Carbohydrates (mostly for dogs)

  • Rice, oatmeal, sweet potatoes, pumpkin.

Vegetables (dog-friendly in moderation)

  • Carrots, peas, green beans, zucchini.

Healthy Fats

  • Fish oil (for omega-3s).
  • Small amounts of olive oil or flaxseed oil.

Supplements (with vet guidance)

  • Taurine for cats.
  • Calcium, vitamin E, or omega-3 supplements if needed.

Practical Tips for Avoiding Dangerous Ingredients

  • Read labels carefully if using store-bought broth or ingredients. Many contain onions, garlic, or excessive salt.
  • Avoid seasoning altogether – pets don’t need herbs, spices, or sauces.
  • Cook food thoroughly to kill bacteria unless you’re following a vet-approved raw feeding protocol.
  • Consult a veterinarian or veterinary nutritionist before starting a homemade diet. Each pet has unique needs based on age, size, and health.

Conclusion

Preparing homemade meals for your cat or dog can be rewarding, but it comes with risks. Understanding the ingredients to avoid in homemade pet food is the first step to keeping your pet safe. From onions and chocolate to xylitol and fatty foods, even seemingly harmless items can have devastating consequences.

The safest approach is to keep meals simple, avoid seasonings, and consult your vet before making dietary changes. With the right knowledge, you can give your pet the benefits of homemade food without endangering their health.

And to discover the best pet products, we would love you to visit our affiliate links below👇

Chewable Dog Vitamins and Supplements for Hip & Joints, Skin & Coat

Dogs and Cats Daily Digestive Health Supplement

Health Liquid Omega-3 Supplement for Dogs and Cats